Supporting Families
  • "Thank you for being there when I needed you. I couldn't have managed without you"
Thursday, 05 May 2011 07:19

Bishop of Rochester Academy (updated 4 May)

Written by  Peter Read

(updates in italics) Latest news on this item here.

I have been asked my views several times in the media over yesterday's shock news of the suspension of the Principal of the new Bishop of Rochester Academy, which opened in September. This was always going to be a difficult task, with two schools with very difficult cultures amalgamating in the old buildings, the new £25 million site not opening until 2013. Both had been led by a successful headteacher, Vince O'Mara, in their final year as preparations were made for the merger, Chatham South School was enjoying success under Vince's leadership, whilst Medway Community College, struggling for many years, emerged from OFSTED Special Measures. There have been considerable behaviour problems since the Academy opened, many coming from friction between the two communities and I have certainly had parents contacting me expressing concerns about behaviour and asking for advice on changing schools or how to complain........
There has been just one discussion at a full Governing Body on the issue of student behaviour at the end of December, when the Principal brought his concerns to the Meeting (Spring Meeting minutes will not have been approved yet). The Minutes record "There had been a severe level of parental complaints to the Local Authority and the local MP about behaviour and discipline at the Academy.  He was very concerned about the negative impact on confidence in the Academy, which had implications for future admissions.  The lack of confidence also impacted on attendance, attainment, behaviour and staff morale". Three meeting of the Governos Monitoring Committee raised concerns about the high level of exclusions,  141 in total in Terms 1 & 2, rising to 254 in Term 3. From all these four meetings, it is clear that both Governors and the School Leadership Team are concerned about poor levels of discipline and developing strategies to deal with them.

Lead sponsor of the Academy is the Diocese of Rochester which explains on the academy website that its expertise is in successful schools in Bromley, Bexley and Tunbridge Wells, very different contexts from urban Chatham. The school website lays great importance on setting the very highest standards for behaviour, learning and achievement, and on its Christian ethos. So far there is little sign of these values permeating through to the school. Medway Council is also a sponsor, and must be concerned about the number of failing schools in the area. Of the fourteen governors, eight are appointed by the Diocese of Rochester, giving them absolute control of the Academy. There is just one parent governor of the Academy - secondary schools normally have around six. It is most unlikely that a single person will carry sufficient weight to influence policy. Likewise there is a single staff governor apart from the Principal. Above them sits an Academy Trust which has four members appointed by the Diocese, and three other members.

One of the problems is that Academies are often set up so that the sponsors "make decisions for the children" from their elevated position and there is often far less involvement of parents and teachers in the governance of the Academy.   Parents were certainly cautious from the beginning, the Academy opening with over a quarter of its places left empty, the highest number of any Medway non selective school, although no worse than half of the other eighteen old style Academies across Kent and Medway. I was asked on Radio Kent this morning about whether discipline in Kent schools is getting worse. Obviously I am not an expert in such matters, my information coming mainly from parental concerns and comments but what is apparent is that leadership is the key factor. That is not just the leadership of the headteacher or Principal but also of governors and, except for Academies, the Local Authority which should have a role.My greatest concern however, is for the children caught up in the controversy whose education and life chances are being damaged, because of the failures of others. Please make no mistake, I accept that discipline is more difficult in many schools, but one is always aware of schools in difficult social areas where good leadership ensures that such problems are minimised.

One question often asked is why the two schools had to merge. Quite simply, pupil numbers are falling sharply in Medway and schools will inevitably have to close or amalgamate. This year, there will be a 10% fall in the number of Year Seven pupils in Medway from 2010.

Company Secretary for the Academy is Rose Collinson, Director of Chidren's Service for Medway Council. One wonders how she has the time!


Last modified on Monday, 16 May 2011 20:54

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated.
Basic HTML code is allowed.